• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

My Kitchen Stories

GET NEW RECIPES AND STORIES DIRECTLY TO YOUR EMAIL HERE

  • Home
  • Recipes
    • Recipes A-to-Z
    • Recipe Index
    • Post Gallery
    • Stacks of Cakes
  • Travel
  • About / Policies
    • ABOUT/DISCLOSURES/POLICIES
    • SERVICES
    • Awards
    • Partners
    • CONTACT
  • Videos

Make ahead Creamy Mashed Potato with Bacon and Cheese

December 13, 2023 by Tania 2 Comments

Sharing is caring!

18 shares
  • Share
  • Tweet
Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Make ahead mashed potato is a discovery for me, how about you?

Make ahead recipes are not new but they are popular for a good reason. Let’s take a look at how you can make the creamiest most incredible mashed potato with bacon and cheese a day or two in advance and enjoy them as much as if they were made today.

Here is how!

Make ahead mash potato in a baking dish

1. Plan ahead.

Making anything ahead of the time you need it, requires a bit of planning. Not all of us are good at planning, however, this idea will have you organising like a pro!

Reasons to plan ahead:

Think about getting home late and having half the dinner ready. Perhaps you have people coming over for a meal and are very time-poor on that day. Maybe it’s a family holiday like Christmas or Easter and you want more time to enjoy just sitting with everyone rather than peeling and mashing potatoes. This little hack will give you a few extra moments when you need them

As my grandmother used to say. A stitch in time saves nine

Potato-with-parmesan-and-bacon-in-a-white-dish.jpg

2. Is mashed Potato good when made ahead?

You bet it is. My hack for mash will surprise you. It’s light and fluffy and will be perfect for making ahead and kept for up to 3 days before reheating. Ensure they are chilled and covered and will be kept in the best condition.

Why hoard potatoes for later?

Think about that cheese and bacon cozying up together then slow cooking in the oven until oozy and melty before the top foil or cover is ripped off and the cheese and bacon becomes golden and bubbly. Should I stop?

Just serve it with a salad and a roasted or pot roasted chicken and you have dinner.

Potato-mashed-with-bacon-in-a-casserole-dish.

3. Trust me I can fit everything in

Starting the meal prep with the best intentions has happened to us all. The next minute everyone is hungry and can’t wait for dinner.

The dinner deal:

We have all slaved over a hot stove to find that by the time dinner is ready too many snacks have been consumed. There are piles of cereal bowls in the sink and the biscuit tin is empty. Make time to prep these potatoes by planning to start the task a bit earlier than normal or when you have extra time. With a big meal like Christmas or a family celebration coming up, save yourself from stressful moments and haul someone else into the kitchen to help do some extra preparing ahead. Ever heard of meal prep days? because we overestimate how long things will take.

See1. Plan ahead

4. The very best way to make mashed potato.

A fork? NO

A potato masher? MAYBE

A potato ricer ABSOLUTELY

Incredible every time mashed potato. Just a few dollars away!

Solution: A potato ricer is the best way to make mashed anything. You won’t need one with changeable disks or any other fancy bits and pieces. Just head straight here or here. Ricers break up all the lumps better than a masher while aerating and lightening. Never make mashed potatoes in a food processor because it makes the potatoes stretchy and very sticky.

potatoes cooked and riced

My top tip for mashed potatoes is that you may be surprised that you do not need to add kilos of butter and cream to make great mash. We cannot possibly eat this kind of mashed potato regularly. I most often make mash with just milk and a medium amount of butter. Salt is what takes mashed potatoes to another level. Salt brings out the flavour of potatoes. A sprinkle of white pepper is also great.

You will find the secret of this dish is that the mash is relatively light and fluffy before we add the bacon, cheese, and sour cream. If you want a delicious mash for every day, hold the cream and sour cream add only milk and some butter, and stir till light and almost softer than you feel necessary. The potatoes will soak up the milk and you will have the perfect everyday fluffy mash.

Preparing-light-mashed-potatoes.

A. Boil the potatoes and add butter and milk after ricing

How to put together make ahead potato mash

B. Once the potatoes are mashed and creamy, they are loaded into a baking dish and spread with the leftover sour cream. Top the dish with cooked bacon and grated parmesan cheese.

Make ahead mash potato ready to be put in the oven
Wrapping potato bake to reheat

C. Reheating needs to be done by using a lid if you have one. If not, tent with foil so the foil doesn’t touch the top of the potato and cheese mixture. You could also add the cheese after it is heated but I like the flavour to penetrate!

Potato-unwrapping-ready-to-brown

Once the potato is heated through the foil is removed and the whole dish is put back into the oven to get bubbly and delicious.


potato-with-a-spoon-taken-out

What to eat with this Mashed Potato?

One Pot Chicken with Mushrooms Baked One Pot chicken with mushrooms

Slow roast lamb with black tahini

Potato-with-parmesan-and-bacon-in-a-white-dish.jpg

Make ahead Creamy Mashed Potato with Bacon and Cheese

5 from 1 vote
Make ahead recipes are not new but they are popular for a good reason. Let's take a look at how you can make the creamiest most incredible mashed potato with bacon and cheese a day or two in advance and enjoy them as much as if they were made today.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 25 minutes mins
Cook Time 50 minutes mins
Servings: 6 serves
Course: dinner, Holiday Food, potato
Cuisine: Australian
Ingredients Method Notes

Ingredients
  

  • 1 kg potato 2 lb
  • 150 ml milk 5 fl oz
  • 100 ml cream 3.5 fl oz
  • 50 gm butter, chopped 1.8oz
  • 300 gm sour cream 10.50oz
  • 200 gm bacon 7 oz
  • 20 ml olive oil 1 tablsp
  • 30 gm parmesan, grated 1 oz
  • 5 gm salt, flaked sea salt
  • extra salt and white pepper to taste

Method
 

Things you can get helpers to do……
  1. a. Oven temperature 200 C/ 390 F.
    b. Prepare a dish. It could be a 20 x17 cm (8x7in) approx. Or if you have a round or square casserole with a lid this will be ideal too!
    c. Bacon will be cooked and cooled in this recipe so cutting bacon and even cooking and cooling while the potatoes are cooking,
    d. Cut up butter and leave it to come to room temperature for easy melting
    e. Grate the cheese
  2. Put the even sized cut and peeled potatoes into a pot and just cover with cold water. salt the water well. Cook the potatoes until soft when a fork is inserted. Drain well to get rid of all water. A sieve is best. Extra water is not wanted here (no flavour and makes potatoes sloppy and hard to rice)
  3. Use a ricer to smash the potato. Add the butter and mix in until melted. Add the cream and milk and 100 gm of sour cream and mix well. The potatoes will be soft and easy to stir.
  4. Pour into a dish approximately 20 x 17 cm (8 x 7 in) or a dish approximately this with a lid if you have one. Spread the potato flat and sit for a couple of minutes to cool a bit. Spread the remaining sour cream over the top of the potatoes by putting puddles of it all over and spreading it with a flat knife
  5. Cut the bacon into small pieces and saute it in the olive oil. Drain and cool and sprinkle over the top of the potatoes and cover with grated cheese. Now you can set the potatoes aside, covered for up to 3 days.
To reheat the Potatoes
  1. Wrap the potatoes in foil. Make sure the foil is tented and doesn't touch the cheese. Set the oven to 200C / 390F. Bake the parcel for 50 minutes. Uncover and bake a further 10 minutes to melt and colour the cheese at the top

Notes

Never let potatoes get cold before mashing them. The starches start to change,  it is impossible to make creamy fluffy mash from cold potatoes. Always have everything ready when you are draining and ricing the potatoes. You can even warm the milk and cream to make sure they are absorbed by the potato more evenly.
Potatoes will take more salt than you think. Even though you will later add cheese and bacon, make sure the potatoes taste like they are seasoned very well before finishing with the toppings. I always use flaked sea salt as it has a very gentle salt flavour and I use up to 2 teaspoons. If you have everyday table salt be cautioned that this will be MUCH stronger and you will need to add and stir and taste a few times.
You may be surprised to know that the best mashed potato is one that has enough seasoning. This makes more difference than all the butter and cream you may add. Salt and a bit of white pepper will bring out the potato flavour
You can use other cheese. I use parmesan for its lovely slightly salty flavour. You could also use pecorino, a cheese that is very similar in flavour and texture but a sheeps milk base. You could use cheddar or mozzarella if you like but I don’t want a stretchy cheesy texture for this dish. It’s all about the potato! Parmesan and Pecorino cheeses are less oily and fatty and won’t leave an oily pool of cheese when baked. 
Use real Parmesan and not the pretend version made in Australia. It will make 100% difference and it is not as expensive as you may think (try Aldi for a good value Italian one)
The recipe serves approximately 6. To feed more people double or triple the recipe. If you have a bigger dish
You can leave off the bacon if you would like a vegetarian option. Sprinkle over chopped parsley or chives
logo for My Kitchen Stories

Sharing is caring!

18 shares
  • Share
  • Tweet

Filed Under: Cheese, Gluten Free, Holiday, RECIPES, Vegetables and Vegetarian Tagged With: baked potato, christmas dishes, gluten free, how to make mashed potato, maincourse items, potato bake, special dishes, vegetable dishes

Previous Post: « Day trip Disasters and How to Avoid them
Next Post: The best collection of Christmas Recipes Ever »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Alphabet

    January 15, 2024 at 6:00 pm

    5 stars
    Made this for a party…everyone loved it! Very quick and simple to make. Really love reading your post Tania.

    Reply
    • Tania

      January 16, 2024 at 7:54 pm

      Thank you. Glad you liked it!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

About Me

Tania Cusack Hi, I'm Tania and this is My Kitchen Stories. I share all kinds of recipes here. Most recipes are quick and easy, just perfect for families. BUT, you could also find vegan, cakes and desserts too. Come and have a look around Read More
facebookTwitterPinterestInstagram
One Pot Cooking Desserts

Footer

GET NEW RECIPES AND STORIES DIRECTLY TO YOUR EMAIL HERE

Copyright © 2026 My Kitchen Stories on the Foodie Pro Theme

18 shares